Participating in History No 3, 2012/2 - pagesPages 5 to 47Comparing Deliberative Practices through the Ages: A Historical Aberration?By Paula Cossart, Julien Talpin, William KeithPages 49 to 69Uproar and Deliberation: Popular Sovereignty in Classical AthensBy Noémie VillacèquePages 71 to 91Deliberation and Involvement in the Roman Republic: An Oligarchy Disguised as DemocracyBy Dominique HiebelPages 93 to 117Convenience and Consent: Public Inquiries in 18th-Century FranceBy Frédéric GraberPages 119 to 140Participation, Discussion, and Representation: The 1848 Club ExperienceBy Samuel HayatPages 141 to 160Forensic Tradition and Democratic Transition: An Alternative History of Rhetoric and Its Public in Early Modern JapanBy Satoru Aonuma, Xavier BlandinPages 161 to 187Shaping Citizens by Public Deliberation: A Tricky Enterprise (United States and France, 1870–1940)By Paula Cossart, William KeithPages 189 to 206For a History of Deliberative PracticesPages 207 to 218Making People Participate: An Issue of Legitimacy for the European UnionBy Romain BadouardPages 219 to 238Why Conversation Is Not the Soul of DemocracyBy Michael Schudson, Charles Girard